A short story
Bad Beat
M.R. Hall
Advanced a round · NYC Midnight Short Story Challenge 2026
Written to the contest's 1,000-word limit.
I turned the hand of five over.
Seven of clubs, four of hearts, king of diamonds, and a pair of nines. Hearts and spades. Potential here—but that wasn’t the point. I took the cigar from my lips, holding it between my fingers as I sipped a glass of whiskey. The single ice cube gently tinged as the Super Chief coasted down the tracks.
Frankie, to my left, took notice. “Ah, suppose I call.”
He knocked on the table, then tossed another ten into the pot.
Dammit. He needed to clear out Lou. I needed to lose. Or we’d have nothing to split. Well, long as Frankie doesn’t start talking bold, means we’re still okay.
“I raise,” Lucky Lou Provenzano said, tossing a ten plus another into the pot. The regal green gently fluttered into the stack. “I thought you said this would be a worthwhile game, Frank.”
“Hey, hey! Don’t you go worryin’ about me, Lou. We still have loads of playin’ left.”
We’re doomed.
We were playing for everything. As in, all we had. Weeks, and weeks of this stupid scheme and he was about to blow it. That was my future in that pot there, course it would turn grim—just my luck!
Two other generic Jacks called, ending the round.
I stared into my own hand.
Suppose…I could try with this…
I put the cigar back in my mouth after another sip of what was the best whiskey I ever had.
Frankie turned his head up. His face spoke not of much, but his eyes sensed the shift.
I flipped the seven and four over, sliding them across the felt. “Two cards.”
The dealer dealt me two cards off the top of the deck. I felt Frankie’s eyes on me. I didn’t look at him as I turned the new cards over.
King of clubs.
Nine of clubs.
Full House. The hand a gambler waits years to see. I had it. Right here, at the worst possible moment.
I pressed forty dollars into the pot. “I bet forty.”
“Swinging big, eh Walt?” Lou said. “All night, not a peep, until right before we close.”
I quelled the shake in my foot, looking over my hand. “Cards’ haven’t been fair tonight, Lou.”
I could see Frankie’s eyebrows raise in my peripheral. The heat was getting to him. He’d start slipping now.
“Callin’ us unfair, Walt?”
“Course not, Lou!” I said, forcing the enthusiasm. “What’s unfair about a stiff drink and a stack of fifty-two?”
Lou chuckled to himself, though it lacked critical humor.
Frankie tossed fifty dollars into the pot. “Call, raise ten!”
Great. That was my fifty for the next two weeks. Which, now, I’d spend stranded in Chicago without. Idiot should have folded. He didn’t get it, he thinks I’ve panicked and he’s covering for me. If he kept this up we’d both be swimming in snow.
A harsh smile played at the corners of Lou’s eyes. “Good idea, I call and raise ten, too.”
One of the Jacks folded. The other called.
I threw in another twenty out of my thinning stack. I tried not to look at anything as Frankie matched without skipping a beat. He added ten more, the last ten. I knew because that was lunch and dinner.
More money than I had ever seen in one place settled between us. So close.
“Looks like it’s about that time, boys,” Lou said.
“Sure seems,” I tossed my open hand down and downed the last of the whiskey.
Lou’s eyes shot open. He slammed his fist down onto the table.
I won. I actually—
Frankie shot out of his seat, his chair flying backwards. Without a word, he shlumf’d off all the cash with an arm, pulling cards and ash trays straight off the table.
Lou and his Jacks shot up. “—What are you—!”
I don’t know how he had made it out of the card room. Or how he got into the next car over. Or how I was behind him, running down the length of this train. But I was, darting over the red carpet that led up to the engine room.
“What the Hell are you doing!” I shouted, running at his side.
“Me? We’ve been made!”
“You idiot! I had won!”
An earth shattering crack fractured my eardrum. A splinter formed in the wood beside me. “Christ! You’ve killed us!”
Frankie pulled his revolver, firing an uncoordinated shot behind us. “Duck!”
“You’re supposed to—” I ducked, another round flying over my head. “—tell me that before you shoot!”
We came to an open door. I shoved Frankie into it. He fell over some actress. She shrieked as I drew my own pistol. Authentic. I took aim, using the room as cover. I laid a shot down the hall. That seemed to stall things. The two Jacks did the same, covering into passenger rooms.
“Now, what!” Frankie yelled, taking cover from a rogue purse.
I fired another round down the hall. “Gee, I don’t know! Maybe think before you swipe!”
“Well, kinda late for that now!”
How I didn’t land lead on him right then and there, I do not know.
I peeked the corner. Shot twice more.
We’re out of time.
“Frankie—engine room! You first!”
“No you—”
I shoved him out. As he launched from the room, I watched his foot catch the red carpet. He tucked, slamming into the far wall. A flurry of green paper whizzed about like a blizzard of wealth. Running past, I scraped him off the floor and hurried us into the engine room, locking us inside. The conductor spun around.
Out of breath, Frankie spoke first. “This is…a…robbery?”
“No, you idiot! This is now a hijacking!”
Then, the train shrilled to a stop at the station.
I don’t much care to reminisce on the rest. I, Frankie, and the Jacks lay face down on the railroad, cuffed and cold. I stared at freezing railway steel. Frankie simply laughed.